GOP looks to final legislative sessions before losing the House majority
Republican state lawmakers have a last chance to pass laws before the GOP loses the grip it’s had on the General Assembly for 15 years — but political and logistical obstacles could limit the party’s ability to make major changes during legislative sessions scheduled for the coming days.
While Republicans are poised to maintain control of the state Senate, Democrats flipped at least 17 state House seats in the midterm elections earlier this month. In January, Democrats will hold a majority in the chamber for the first time since 2010, giving them newfound influence over the state’s finances and policies.
House members this week plan to address vacancies on state commissions, examine state agency funding and discuss the potential for more aid to Hurricane Helene victims, House Speaker Destin Hall’s office said Friday. But Democrats are worried that their Republican colleagues might go further and use their final weeks of House control to ram through partisan legislation that might not pass under a Democratic majority.
Rep. Zack Hawkins, a Durham Democrat, told WRAL that he has been calling Republican colleagues to see if they’re up to any “shenanigans” — such as bills that strip Democratic officials of power or fund controversial projects. While Hawkins said he has received no confirmation, he said he wouldn’t be surprised if Republican leaders whip up divisive legislation before the end of the year.
“I’d say it’s 50-50 on whether or not shenanigans are going to happen,” Hawkins said, noting that state lawmakers left $1 billion unspent in this year’s budget - money they could use for priorities now.
“That's honestly why I can't put anything past them,” Hawkins said.
Rep. Erin Paré, a Wake County Republican who cochairs the House Appropriations Committee, told WRAL she’s not aware of any plans to spend frivolously or strip Democrats of power. Republicans are drafting a technical corrections bill that they hope Democratic Gov. Josh Stein will support.
“Anyone expecting us to go haywire next week will be sorely disappointed,” Paré said in a Friday interview.
Republican legislators have previously used so-called “lame-duck sessions” — convening after an election, but before new legislators are sworn in — to enact laws that strip power from Democrats.
After Stein won the 2024 gubernatorial race, the GOP-controlled General Assembly shifted control of the North Carolina State Board of Elections to the incoming state auditor, Republican Dave Boliek.
The new law also banned the attorney general — a position won in 2024 by Democrat Jeff Jackson — from opposing the legislature in court. Stein filed legal challenges to the law and is now awaiting a ruling by the state Supreme Court, which heard oral arguments last week. The law also stripped away oversight powers from Stein and Jackson over the state Utilities Commission, which regulates Duke Energy and sets electrical rates.
Rep. Pricey Harrison, D-Guilford, was in office in 2016 when the Republican-led legislature stripped powers from incoming Gov. Roy Cooper. Like Hawkins, Harrison said she had spoken with a few House Republicans about their legislative plans for the rest of the year.
The mood amongst Republicans seems different this year than it was in 2016, Harrison said.
“What I hear from talking to my colleagues across the aisle is that there's mixed feelings about being aggressive,” she said. “Some members aren't keen on it. Especially the ones that lost just aren't feeling particularly vindictive and just think we should do the people's business — not engage in aggressive power stripping.”
She added: “But you never know.”
Even if Republicans secure support for upcoming legislation from a Democratic or independent member, they may struggle to lure their own caucus members back to Raleigh. Health issues, holiday vacation plans and other scheduling conflicts could deter legislators from returning.
Hall has acknowledged that Rep. John Sauls, R-Lee, has faced health issues. Sauls has missed all but three voting days this year and has accumulated 498 excused absences over the last two years, legislative records show.
Others may have personal reasons for missing votes.
Rep. Keith Kidwell, R-Beaufort, has missed several votes since losing his March primary to a Republican challenger, Darren Armstrong, who won the seat unopposed in the general election. Kidwell missed votes this summer for the state budget and several other bills — absences that party leaders excused, according to legislative records. He also missed several votes in August that were not excused. Kidwell didn’t respond to a request for comment Friday.
Other factors could also cause attendance issues for any number of lawmakers, on either side of the aisle: Those who aren’t already retired have likely missed weeks or months of work on the campaign trail this year, and they may have been counting on this post-election period to return to their jobs rather than going back into session. Plus, with Republicans out of the House majority for the next two years, legislative leaders have fewer resources to offer members as an incentive to drive to Raleigh for a lame-duck session.
One action legislators could take without worrying about Stein’s veto pen: redrawing the state’s congressional maps. State law doesn’t allow for the governor to veto redistricting efforts. A spokesperson for Senate leader Phil Berger, R-Rockingham, declined to answer WRAL’s questions about potentially redrawing congressional maps. Berger was the leading force behind the 2025 redraw. A spokesperson for Hall said the House Speaker doesn’t plan on introducing new congressional maps.
Map Backfire
When legislative Republicans redrew the state's 1st and 3rd Congressional Districts last fall in an effort to give the party an advantage in both of them instead of just one, they were clear about their purpose. "The end result is a map that should perform to elect 11 Republicans," Sen. Ralph Hise, R-Mitchell, told the Senate Elections Committee while presenting the map last Oct. 20. The map actually elected 11 Democrats.
And beyond that, the specific decision in fall 2025 to strengthen Republicans' advantage in northeastern North Carolina's 1st Congressional District not only failed to unseat incumbent Democratic Rep. Don Davis, but also helped Democratic challenger Raymond Smith defeat incumbent Republican Rep. Greg Murphy in the neighboring 3rd Congressional District.
This is what political scientists refer to as a "dummymander," a term coined in 2005 by political scientists Bernard Grofman and Thomas L. Brunell to refer to situations where a party's effort to give itself an electoral advantage by redrawing maps ends up favoring its opponents.
"You almost couldn't draw up a better textbook example than what they did in the 1st and the 3rd because it did not touch any other district in the state," said Chris Cooper, the director of the Haire Institute for Public Policy at Western Carolina University. "They said the point of it out loud, to get Don Davis out of office to get another Republican in and to hold onto the 3rd. And they failed and they failed."
If Republicans had simply not redrawn the map, it appears likely that Murphy would have been re-elected to Congress.
The Wikipedia page for "dummymandering" was updated Wednesday morning to show the map that Republicans drew last fall in an effort to give their party the advantage in 11 Congressional races, up from 10 in 2024. Democrats won both the Third and First Congressional Districts, which were drawn in an attempt to yield two Republican Congressmen instead of one.
While it's impossible to make a direct comparison because candidate quality and incumbency both matter, Republican challenger Laurie Buckhout won the six counties moved into the 1st Congressional District by a margin of 18,023 votes. That's well more than the 293-vote margin by which Murphy is trailing after provisional ballots were counted.
Conversely, Smith won the four counties moved into the 3rd Congressional District by 2,532 votes, largely driven by Wilson County. Murphy led the race after election day, going so far as to declare victory in the early morning hours of November 4. But Smith flipped the district after provisional ballots were counted, and Murphy conceded Wednesday morning.
The North Carolina example is so on-the-nose that the Wikipedia page for the term "dummymandering" was updated early Wednesday, just hours after Smith took the lead, to show the comparison of the state's 2024 and 2026 Congressional maps as its lead image.
"Congrats to @NCGOP on becoming the encyclopedia example of a dummymander. I hope this will motivate you to spend less time suppressing voters and more time delivering for them!," Democratic 2nd District Rep. Deborah Ross wrote in a social media post on X.
North Carolina's 2025 redistricting took place in a national environment where Republican-controlled state legislatures redrew districts to try to give their Congressional candidates significant advantages, and Democratic-controlled states responded. The trend started in Texas, with California quickly responding. In North Carolina, like in many states, mapmakers used results from the 2024 presidential election to draw the new districts.
With that in mind, Hise told the committee last October that the 1st District went from one where Trump won 51% of the vote in 2024 to one where he would have won 55%. The 3rd District declined from one where Trump won 60% of ballots to one where he won 56%.
"The motivation behind this new plan is straightforward: The new Congressional map improves Republicans' critical strength in eastern North Carolina," Hise said. Relying on the 2024 presidential election to draw the new maps could have been a strategic error, Cooper said.
"Ralph Hise might have made a mistake that a lot of people made, which was to assume that the 2024 election, whether the presidential or anything down-ballot, is the norm," Cooper said. “What we might have learned last Tuesday is that really the 2024 election was probably the high-water mark for Republicans."
Former lawmaker faces embezzlement indictment related to bourbon tour
A lobbyist and former top North Carolina lawmaker is facing criminal charges from a Wake County grand jury stemming from an April 2024 bourbon tour for North Carolina lawmakers in Kentucky.
The indictment, handed down earlier this week, charges former state Rep. Jason Saine, a Republican from Lincoln County, with felony embezzlement of more than $100,000 and obtaining property by false pretense. He was also charged with aiding and abetting the same acts by the group’s executive director, David Coble, who was indicted as well this week.
“I do not understand why I have been charged in this case,” Saine said in a statement. “The indictment claims that I ‘aided and abetted’ a crime committed by someone else — I did not do that.” Saine declined to provide further comment, but said in the statement, “I did not commit any crime and I look forward to clearing my name.”
The junket was arranged and funded by Greater Carolina, a 501(c)4 advocacy group connected to Saine and founded by a former Saine staffer. It’s sometimes referred to as a dark money group because it doesn’t publicly disclose its donors.
Greater Carolina described itself as a nonprofit conservative social welfare organization aiming to promote pro-business and free-market policies in North Carolina. The group no longer has an online presence. Federal tax law allows for 501(c)4 social welfare groups to lobby for legislation, but they cannot intervene in political campaigns or have political activities as their primary purpose.
The Kentucky trip gained attention across the Tar Heel State after a Louisville-area hospitality worker made an anonymous social media post saying the group had booked a private bourbon tasting, but was already inebriated when they arrived.
Wake County District Attorney Lorrin Freeman said the charges come from an ongoing multi-year investigation into Greater Carolina.
“From the beginning, the focus of this investigation has been to determine what, if any, laws were violated in the operation of this organization,” Freeman said in a statement. “This case serves as a reminder that the law places restrictions on the way they operate and sets forth that they should not be used as an end run around the statutory framework embodied in our state’s Ethics Act and lobbying regulations.”
Freeman said when her term ends, the case will transition to District Attorney-elect Wiley Nickel.
Earlier this year, four prominent North Carolina lobbyists were also indicted on criminal charges related to the 2024 trip. They each faced a misdemeanor charge of solicitation to commit violations of the offense of giving gifts by lobbyists and lobbying principals.
Three of those four lobbyists had their cases cleared in September, while pending charges remain against the fourth, Kevin Wilkinson of The Southern Group. The indictment against Wilkinson claimed Greater Carolina paid for the trip “with the intent that an ultimate beneficiary of those contributions would be legislators.”
At the time of the Kentucky trip, Saine was a top state budget writer in the North Carolina House. He resigned from the legislature in August 2024, joining The Southern Group lobbying firm. Saine now leads his own firm, Saine Strategies
Lame duck session comes with an uncertain agenda
The state legislature is scheduled to return to Raleigh next week, but no one seems to know what's on the agenda, when votes will take place, or how long it will last.
While Democrats won control of the state House in last week's election (and Republicans lost seats in the Senate), current lawmakers will remain in office until Dec. 31. That means Republicans still have a veto-proof majority in the Senate and what they call a "working supermajority" in the House. And in past elections where Republicans have lost seats or key statewide races, they've convened after the election to pass measures shifting power away from Democrats. But just days before this year's lame-duck session is set to convene next Monday, no information has been released about legislative leaders' plans.
"If I'm being honest with you, I've not seen a plan," House Rules Chairman John Bell, R-Wayne, told WUNC News on Wednesday. "I've not seen the agenda. I've not seen anything. Neither has anyone else in the caucus." Bell says he thinks lawmakers will be back in Raleigh on Tuesday, a day after the session's formal start.
Spokespeople for Senate leader Phil Berger and House Speaker Destin Hall also said this week that they did not have any information yet about the session agenda or schedule.
Both Berger and Hall have been quiet since Election Day. Berger has not issued a public statement or posted on social media in about a month, aside from a brief post on Wednesday recognizing Veterans Day. Hall sent out a news release around 1 a.m. on election night congratulating Democrats on their wins, but his typically active social media accounts haven't posted since Election Day, nor has he made any other public statements. The House Republican Caucus' social media account has also gone dark.
The legislature's adjournment resolution gives some scheduling framework for the rest of the year, but it's unclear which dates could see votes or other legislative action. It calls for the House and Senate to be in session from Nov. 16-19, before taking a Thanksgiving break and potentially returning on Nov. 30. After that date, the legislature could be in session until a Dec. 18 date to adjourn "sine die," which means its business is concluded until the newly elected lawmakers take office in 2027.
The lack of information about legislative leaders' plans for the coming weeks has Democrats worried about what might be coming.
"It's still a mystery," Senate Minority Leader Sydney Batch, D-Wake, told WUNC News on Monday. "But what we have heard is conversations about the House Republicans wanting to spend a lot of the money in the reserves, and to make sure that makes it harder for the Democrats to have any money left to spend."
Batch says she's also heard rumors that Republicans could try to change who's responsible for prosecuting public corruption cases. That duty currently belongs to the Wake County district attorney, an office that former Democratic Congressman Wiley Nickel will occupy next year. Nickel has vowed to make those cases a top priority.
Batch said she'd rather see the legislature take a break over the holidays and return in the new year. "But if they want to be Grinches and go ahead and come back and steal from the coffers of North Carolinians, and do whatever they think that they need to do, then, by all means," she said.
"I just want them all to remember that January is coming, and they're going to have to work with the new members that are actually in the majority (in the House). So it's going to be very difficult for them to get anything passed, especially in the House, if they decide to take a really hard line and make sure that they spend a ton of money."
In a Tuesday news conference, incoming House Speaker Robert Reives, D-Chatham, had a similar warning to his GOP colleagues.
"If we come in here with the lame-duck sessions that we've had every cycle since I've been here, then that will be a signal to the (Democratic) caucus that there is no interest in working with us, and there's no interest in any bipartisanism or camaraderie" next year, Reives said. "I don't want business as usual."
Reives said he's also received no information so far about the legislature's schedule for the remainder of the year. He'd prefer to see "the bare minimum that you need to do, as far as any cleanup we've got to do from the budget process or something like that."
In addition to budget or spending bills, a range of other items could be on the agenda:
- Veto overrides: House Republicans have a total of five vetoes from Gov. Josh Stein that they haven't yet tried to override. They include a bill to repeal the permit requirements to carry a concealed handgun, controversial changes to election laws and changes to eviction laws. Senate Republicans, meanwhile, still haven't scheduled an override vote on a bill to ban diversity, equity and inclusion policies and programs in state government.
- Property taxes: After voters overwhelmingly approved a constitutional amendment to restrict property taxes, lawmakers need to decide what those restrictions will be. It's unclear whether that will happen in the lame-duck session or wait until next year; Stein could veto a bill implementing the amendment, which could force lawmakers to try again if they can't get the three-fifths majorities needed for an override before the December adjournment.
- Appointment powers: Control over appointments to state boards and commissions has been a common theme in previous lame-duck sessions. Republicans have sought to shift power from the governor to the legislature or to other statewide offices held by Republicans, such as the state auditor.
Stein and previous Gov. Roy Cooper have consistently vetoed those measures, so whether Republicans could succeed in a power shift depends on whether they could get enough GOP legislators (and perhaps two former House Democrats who lost primaries and left their party) in the room at the same time for an override vote. With many incumbents leaving office soon, that could be easier said than done.
Hatteras Repairs
The N.C. Department of Transportation is seeking permission from the federal government to move about 3,300 feet of N.C. 12 deeper into the Pea Island National Wildlife Refuge to try to prevent it from being washed out by the ocean. N.C. 12, the only highway access to Hatteras Island, would move as much as 180 feet inland, away from the sand dunes that have twice failed to protect the road from ocean surf this fall. Nor’easters in late September and mid-October washed away the dunes and destroyed more than 1,200 feet of pavement. Only one lane of the highway has reopened near the wildlife refuge visitors center, with portable traffic lights alternating north- and south-bound traffic. It will likely remain that way for several weeks as NCDOT works to restore the sand dunes before restoring a second lane and fully reopening the road. On Friday, NCDOT began placing the first of about 1,100 sandbags between the road and the surf in hopes of protecting the pavement in future storms. Shifting N.C. 12 inland would require moving or replacing the wildlife refuge visitors center. NCDOT needs approval from federal officials, including the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, which owns and manages the refuge.